The Patriot Act is obviously a boon for homegrown tyrants. Only slightly less obvious is the fact that it won’t be able to protect us from their bogeymen, even though that’s the only excuse they can publicly offer for its existence.
Bloggy draws the properly scary conclusion from today’s headlines.
Category: Politics
future present
(storyboard image for filing cabinet scene not included in the film)
I saw Terry Gilliam’s “Brazil” in a movie theatre when it first came out, almost twenty years ago. I remember thinking it was exciting and pretty funny. B and I saw it again tonight at home. This time I thought it was terrifying. In 2004 it’s no longer “retro future.”
Another big surprise: Jonathan Pryce is really cute as Sam Lowry. I didn’t remember that.
[image at the top from Trond Frittz lower image from MovieGoods]
political trial, political prisoners
serious street theatre: Rachel Corrie remembered on 5th Avenue, March 26, 2003
Barry and I slipped into Manhattan Criminal Court on Monday to show support for our friends and their friends, sixteen defendents caught up in the trial from mayhem (maybe the word “hell” should be reserved for even more horrendous judicial outrages likely still to come).
Thirteen months ago the group had been arrested for a totally peaceful street protest against the war in Iraq, against the continuing war on the Palestinians, and against the death of U.S. human rights activist Rachel Corrie. Ok, some traffic was disrupted on 5th Avenue. Now those arrested that day may be subject to restraint of their liberties during years of probation and, in the words of hanging judge Robert M. Stolz on Monday, they are “facing a possible sentence of up to a year in jail.” A year in jail? For blocking cars? For trying to shake their country awake?
Stolz’s mention of the serious stakes involved for the defendents followed immediately a thinly-veiled warning to their friends and familiy in the benches: “[This trial] is not for the benefit of Spectators.” No, it certainly isn’t, but can we know for whose benefit it is being staged?
This trial is an appalling abuse of the courts. We used to think that Giuliani’s regime* was outrageous, but to experience an even more serious assault New Yorkers really had to wait until after the reactionary ascendancy which followed the 2000 election, after the misreading of September 11, after the terrorists won the war on terror the day it was announced, and after the totally political decision that New York City would be the site of the Republican Convention celebrating the arrival of the fundamentalists’ brave new world.
Normally political protest which involves a police determination that the protestor
is somehow out of order results in a simple violation and the dismissal of all charges, assuming the person arrested does not run into the police again within a designated relatively short period of time, usually a few months.
I can’t begin to go into the particulars here of how this judge and this district attorney (Morgenthau’s lieutenant, Barry Glasser) have been mishandling the case of the “5th Avenue 16,” but let me say that neither party is disinterested, and that the people’s justice appears to be just about the last concern of both. Not incidently, aside from carrying an axe which will apparently never be ground enough, Judge Stolz has to be faulted for incredibly slovenly, unprofessional conduct. But then, these are also times which somehow accomodate a George W. Bush presiding over 300 million [or actually 6 billion] of his fellows.
Yesterday morning, for what was expected to be only the pronouncement of sentences, there were at all times a minimum of eight police officers in the courtroom on Monday (one for every ten people in the public seating area) and four of them wore bulletproof vests. I have been a defendent in civil rights cases, I have sat in courtrooms while others were tried for similar “offenses” and I have sat on the jury in one capital case. Never before have I have seen more than two officers in a courtroom, and none were ever wearing vests.
Clearly the City authorities and their directors in Washington are trying very hard to frighten us all into submission and to minimize the potential for the demonstrations and protest which are the only refuge for a people given no effective electoral choices. We can’t let our self-appointed governors get away with this. The stakes are just too high. If we fail to stop these police state tactics now, we all will be paying for it for years, if not forever.
Clyde Haberman has written one of the very few media stories on this trial. He doesn’t tell us enough, he provides no real context, and he may be trying to be too entertaining, but you’ll at least learn that sentencing has been delayed contemplating the impact of new evidence. True justice’s hope is that the defendents’ lawyer will be successful in his motion for an appeal, but with this judge it must be a distant hope at best.
For more press and other information, including pictures, go to M26.org
*
Surprise! A former federal prosecutor, Stolz was originally appointed Judge by Giuliani, to the Civil Court in 1995. He was appointed to the Criminal Court by Bloomberg in 2003.
[image from Fred Askew]
April 15, the steps of the Post Office
“TAXES ARE NOT FOR EVERYONE”
“TALK LOUDLY AND CARRY A BIG DICK”
“WE’VE PAID OUR TAXES, NOW LET US GET MARRIED”
By 6:30 this evening, on the last day for mailing income tax returns, the steps of the Main Post Office on 8th Avenue were getting pretty lively. In addition to an ungoodly [sic] number of police, there were at least three distinct groups demonstrating, including Billionaires For Bush, the Missile Dick Chicks, and Marriage Equality New York.
Even if it’s not really surprising these days, it’s still depressing for a queer with a sense of history and occasion to have to report that the last group was the least entertaining, and certainly the least theatrical of the bunch. It’s true that there are certainly more important criteria for judging the merits of a cause, but what’s become of our creative standards? Don’t we owe something to the rich imaginations of the millions of unmarrieds who have gone before us?
Keith’s anger, and his love
the same Keith Cylar who won the respect of civic officials for his tireless work with Housing Works clients was arrested more than 50 times for civil disobedience: here he is shown visiting the U.S. Senate chambers*
WBAI’s site now has posted part of an absolutely amazing interview which Ben Shepard made with Keith Cylar a little over two years ago.
Keith describes his first experience with AIDS, beginning in the early 80’s, and what his world was like at the time.
At that point I was having sex wherever. It was really schizophenic; there was the fear of contagion, but the unforgiving presence of hormones and the need to have sex. I don’t regret it. I actually wish that I had more sex than I had back then but I was a prude. I was a nerd. I cried a lot back then because of how lonely I was. It was a very alienated world which didn’t necessarily know how to deal with a strong, black, intelligent, jock male who is also a faggot who loves men and loves kinky sex.
Later in the interview Ben asks Keith about ACT UP’s Housing Committee, founded in the late 80’s, which was the forerunner of Housing Works.
BS: What about this Housing Committee? When did housing become an AIDS issue? When did Housing and AIDS become linked? Its not part of everybody’s consciousness?
KC: Let me tell you what was happening. There was a gridlock in the hospital system. Charlie King, Ginny Shubert, Eric Sawyer started recognizing the issue in ’88, ’87. For me working in the hospital, I couldn’t get people out of the hospital because they didn’t have a place to live. We’d get ’em well from whatever brought them in; they wouldn’t have a place to live. They’d stay in the hospitals and they’d pick up another thing and then they’d die. Remember, 88, 90, 91, 92–New York City literally had hospital gridlock and that was when they were keeping people out on hospital gurneys in the hallways. That was when people were not being fed, bathed or touched. It was horrendous. You can’t imagine what it was like to be black, gay, a drug user, transgender, and dying from AIDS.
So housing all of a sudden became this issue. ACT UP recognized it and formed this Housing Committee. I got involved in the Housing Committee when they came to the Majority Action Committee to do a presentation, asking us to help them get money from the floor to go to the First National African American Conference on AIDS. It was going to be in Washington [D.C.]. There was this guy there, Charles King, I sort of ripped into Charles King. We started working together.
The strategy was to push, push, push. It wasn’t different than the general ACT UP strategy about inclusion. But it was always to get those populations also included.
It was easy for the world to deal with gay white men. People of color were so far off the Richter scale, and it was also to hold people of color organizations accountable.
If it was the worst of times, people like Keith made it also some of the best of times.
A lot of this stuff for me became very emotional but I have not focused on it because I plan to do this work for a long time and I have learned. This is the problem that happened with ACT UP. You cannot last forever on anger. You cannot last forever on the negative side of emotions. And you really have to learn how to love. And you have to go to much more positive spaces ultimately if you are going to do this for a long time.
And part of what happened with ACT UP was its evolution had to do not only with this intense creative thing and very brilliant people who created and populated and ran organizations. They were so competitive and so angry and bitter at the outside world and they needed [to] be because we were literally fighting for our lives. But inside we needed to learn how to love. We needed to learn how to care for each other. We needed to learn that I wasn‚t necessarily your enemy.
BS: There was also the recognition that doing AIDS work meant doing race, class, and gender work.
KC: That came for people of color. We were trying to do that and they were doing “Drugs into Bodies.” So there was always this contention. When ACT UP worked well and there was a real consensus process and you could talk about stuff and you could talk it through, you could work together. And that was when it worked well. The fights that happened out of that lead to people splintering. You cannot build a community in hate, you cannot build a community on anger. You cannot build a community on death and dying. The overwhelming thing about the AIDS epidemic is they died.
We haven’t heard the end of Keith’s story, especially since his work survives as a very succcessful multi-million dollar service organization which has not compromised its activism or its principles. It’s established itself as a very visible and indispensible institution in communities virtually ignored otherwise, if not positively despised.
From almost the beginning, Housing Works has even managed to be considered very chic at the same time as it was saving lives. This was an association which was undoubtedly enormously important both for its fundraising and for the additional self-respect such a cachet was able to encourage among its clients, employees, volunteers and defenders at the barricades.
Remarkably, these were all roles which might be shared even at the same moment by the people associated with Housing Works. Attracting this kind of commitment was another reflection of the large souls both of Charles King and of the good companion we have just lost.
[the image at the top was provided by Terri Smith-Caronia at Housing Works]
UPDATED:
[I neglected to mention yesterday that the interview posted on the WBAI site is credited there: An excerpt from the book From ACT UP to the WTO: Urban Protest And Community-Building in the Era of Globalization Edited by Benjamin Shepard and Ronald Hayduk]
The April 8 NYTimes includes an obituary: “Keith Cylar, 45; Found Homes for AIDS Patients”
Keith Cylar
A beautiful man died yesterday.
Keith Cylar was the Co-Founder and Co-President of Housing Works, whose good people announced his death today. Keith had lived with HIV for over 20-years and was diagnosed with AIDS in 1989. In the last year, Keith developed cardiomyopathy, a serious enlargement of the heart. He died in his sleep early Monday morning of a cardioarythmia.
Fellow troublemaker and troublesolver Eric Sawyer reminds us of how much we have lost.
UPDATED:I remember when Charles King first brought Keith Cylar to a meeting of the Housing Committee. Keith had aready been coming to ACT UP – was working for the Minority AIDS Task Force in Harlem and was involved with the Minority (soon to become Majority) AIDS Action Committee.
Keith was this strong, tough as nails, sweet as sugar, fearless scared man child, angry at the loss of his former lover, fierce with rage against the do nothings in power; a handsome, sexy, powerful man – wise beyond his years – determined to help right the wrongs the world was doing to PWAs, to the poor, to the homeless, to the voiceless and to disenfranchised.
Keith was an out, proud, queer, black, positive brother when it was definitely not cool to be so in his community – a leader amongst men and a hero amongst warriors – Keith was my friend and I love him so.
Keith was able to kick back with a homeless person on a street corner, dance with a member of the Congress, break bread with a former Mayor, sip wine with a Cabinet Member and debate a member of the First Family with equal ease. He could also hold the hand of the dying and help them make peace with the Universe.
The world has a huge whole in it’s soul now that Keith has left this plain.
I looked everywhere last night for at least one great picture to include at the top of this post, but with no luck. I think it says a great deal about both Keith and Charles that they seem almost invisible; the work is big, the egos are not.
[April 10: I now have two images, thanks to Terri Smith-Caronia at Housing Works, one sitting at the top of this post and the second at the top of the the April 7 followup]
stupidity and iniquity
The Bushites and their handlers: Although somehow they hijacked command of the most powerful country on earth, they clearly don’t know what they’re doing and they’re doing it for the wrong reasons.
I used to think that their stupidity is what would save the planet, but that was before the “war on terror,” the war on Afghanistan, the war on Iraq and now the wars which will be visited upon the entire world in response to their stupidity and iniquity.
armageddon, finally, again
It may finally have come down to our millennialists against their millennialists.
Over the weekend a new war may have begun began in earnest in Iraq, a very visible, coordinated, religion-based uprising against the occupation. The Christian soldiers running the U.S. and Iraq these days are driven by visions of the second coming of Jesus. The Iraqi streets and basements are propelled by the appearance of the Mahdi. Unfortunately the two armies are talking about roughly the same thing – the end of the world – but they aren’t going to make it easy for anyone.
The Mahdi Army is the name given to the militia responsible for the current outbreaks of violence. People who study British, african, middle-east and asian history know the enormous significance the name Mahdi assumed at the end of the 19th century when it was both bogeyman and a real terrorist threat for the last bible-thumping, English-speaking empire. At least the reportedly quite observant Blair should remember Gordon and Kitchener, especially this week.
[image originally from Wired]
tin can phones here and a tin security everywhere
Ray Sanchez has found New York City transit’s Achilles heel, or at least the one vulnerability which is most likely to endanger the lives of the millions of people who use the system every day – a vulnerability which would be devastating after a terrorist hit, since survivors may then have to get out of the tunnels to remain survivors.
It has long been known that the Metropolitan Transportation Authority and New York City Transit have problems communicating effectively with its customers. This was most evident anytime transit officials were asked to explain fare increases and service cuts.
But in a time of train bomb massacres, it is becoming disturbingly apparent that the people who run the New York subway system also have difficulty communicating with one another – including when lives are at stake.
Read Sanchez’s report on Annie Chamberlin’s experience February 29.
But stupidity and incompetence, if not criminal malfeasance in this post 9/11 world, is not limited to New York’s planners and administrators. The Bush administration budget for the upcoming fiscal year calls for $5.3 billion for transportation security, but only $147 million of it is allocated for everything other than air security. That $147 million is supposed to cover ports, roads, bridges, tunnels, power plants and rail systems.
And what is it we’re now told we have to pay for an Iraq war which had absolutely nothing to do with terrorism, fear of which the administration hopes to use to maintain its power? Was it $100 billion? But much more important, I’m thinking that so far the cost is the nearly 600 American lives alone, and the thousands (again only the American count) injured or maimed.
We shouldn’t tolerate the use of terror for political purposes. The Bush regime and its lieutenants have to be thrown out before we cash in more than just our freedoms in exchange for a tin security.*
PAZ.
____________________
*
The evidence could be stacked up forever, but one inarguable fact reported today in the Washington Post [via Atrios] should alone be enough to demolish any remaining illusions about either the sincerity or the competence of the gang in the White House, above all when it’s a question of protecting us from terrorists.
In the early days after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, the Bush White House cut by nearly two-thirds an emergency request for counterterrorism funds by the FBI, an internal administration budget document shows.
. . . .
The papers show that Ashcroft ranked counterterrorism efforts as a lower priority than his predecessor did, and that he resisted FBI requests for more counterterrorism funding before and immediately after the attacks.
. . . .
“Despite multiple terror warnings before and after 9/11, [Bush] repeatedly rejected counterterrorism resources that his own security agencies said was desperately needed to protect America,” said David Sirota, spokesman for [the Center for American Progress, a liberal group run by former Clinton chief of staff John D. Podesta], which plans to post the documents on its Web site today.the myria network]
100,000 missing in Manhattan streets
in Madison Avenue this afternoon
What if they threw a demonstration and everbody came, except the media? Would you be able to get people into the streets next time? Think about it, while you search for coverage of the massive antiwar demonstration in New York today, and especially if you’re looking in the New York Times. See bloggy for the story about the missing story.
Is the conservative U.S. establishment still afraid to show the popular opposition to a disastrous goverment and its disastrous foreign adventures, even when those disasters have finally become so obvious? Does it think a crude media blackout will discourage its critics? And, more important, will it?
While I’m also thinking just now that the demonstrators who marched out to Versailles in 1789 didn’t need the NYTimes to help them bring their own king back to Paris, where he was capitally eliminated a few years later, I have to admit that the French have generally been much more courageous about seeing that their governments remain responsible than we have.
Later this afternoon I expect to have a gallery of about two dozen photos up on this post, taken while we marched with Palestinians and Jews Against the Occupation.
—
UPDATED: Photos are now here; captions will arrive later on Sunday.
—
UPDATED: Captions are now atteached to the photos.